Michael Abrahams | The trouble with the Speaker
Loading article...
Juliet Holness was elected Speaker of the House of Representatives in September 2023. However, since assuming office, her tenure has been dogged by controversy.
One grievance is her marriage to the prime minister, which raises a conflict-of -interest concern. Her supporters insist that no rules were broken during her appointment and that she is qualified for the position. They are correct. The rules stipulate that the appointee must be an elected member of the House who is not a minister or parliamentary secretary, and Mrs Holness satisfies these requirements.
However, compliance with rules does not mean that the appointment is fair. A conflict of interest arises when competing personal and professional loyalties have the potential to compromise an individual’s duties or decision-making. In Mrs Holness’ case, those competing loyalties would be to her marriage and to the Parliament and the country. Being married and being the Speaker carry important responsibilities, and maintaining both would be in Mrs Holness’ best interest. And this is where the challenge can arise. For instance, if she receives a report that is likely to embarrass the prime minister, it could present a genuine conflict for her. If she tables it expeditiously, it could strain her marriage. Conversely, if she delays tabling it to protect her spouse and her marriage, it would constitute a dereliction of her parliamentary responsibilities.
Some have argued that the opposition leader’s reference to Mrs Holness as the prime minister’s wife is misogynistic, but that claim is ludicrous. It has nothing to do with gender. When Portia Simpson Miller was prime minister, if her husband had been appointed Speaker, the same concerns would have arisen. The issue is not about gender; it is about the Speaker’s proximity to the prime minister.
Interestingly, on Mrs Holness’ Instagram profile, the first four descriptions in her biography appear in this order:
Politician
Mother of two
Wife of @Andrewholnessjm
Speaker of the House of Representatives
In the bio, being the wife of the prime minister takes precedence over being Speaker. I also recall a video of a big Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) political meeting in which a fellow Labourite introduced her as “the wife of the prime minister”, to riotous applause. So, lambasting the opposition leader for using the same description is hypocritical.
Our parliamentary system is already inherently flawed. The Speaker is required to be an MP of the governing party, meaning they have already picked a side. It is difficult to be impartial when you belong to a side, which is why in international football matches the referee cannot be from one of the competing countries. The Speaker is Parliament’s referee and should therefore at least try to be impartial. However, Mrs Holness has not been a convincing impartial arbiter. For instance, at a recent political meeting she told supporters, “Mek mi tell unno something, yuh see anything yuh hear whey nuh good bout Labourite, a lie.” Such a sweeping endorsement of her party suggests that she believes it is immune to criticism, which demonstrates extreme bias and is also disingenuous. This is not the only thing she has done that has cast doubt on her fairness and credibility.
Holness claimed that, during the parliamentary brouhaha on November 3, Opposition MP Angela Brown Burke physically assaulted her. A widely circulated video showed Brown Burke’s right hand appearing to shove Holness’ left shoulder as Holness walked past her in the parliamentary aisle. However, the official recording of the sitting, streamed live by the Public Broadcasting Corporation of Jamaica (PBCJ), does not appear to substantiate her allegations. Mrs Holness also denied turning off the microphones on opposition MPs during the contentious sitting. Yet, the official footage shows the audio being cut on several occasions, which raises another issue: the silencing of the Opposition.
Standing Orders must be upheld and, if parliamentarians violate them, the Speaker has the right to shut them down. But Holness weaponises the Standing Orders. For instance, there are instances where the Standing Orders allow the Speaker to use her discretion, but she has used that discretion to curtail Opposition participation.
There are also several instances where she has ignored Opposition parliamentarians when they attempted to get her attention and permission to speak, and many others where she has muted their microphones, including that of the opposition leader. When she addresses opposition MPs, her tone is sometimes abrasive and her attitude dismissive. She has also faced repeated accusations of delaying the tabling of reports from the Auditor General and the Integrity Commission.
Jamaica has had 13 Speakers since Independence and, to the best of my knowledge, none has been at the centre of as much controversy as Mrs Holness. Over the past three years, she has featured prominently in several parliamentary upheavals. In March 2024, the prime minister and JLP MPs walked out of Gordon House during Opposition Leader Mark Golding’s budget debate presentation when he said that the head of Parliament’s being the spouse of the head of Government “does not sit well with the tradition that the Speaker must act independently of the government of the day”. In April, the infamous mace-lifting incident occurred after Opposition MP Angela Brown Burke claimed that Holness ignored her repeated attempts to get her attention. More recently, the catalyst for the fracas on November 3 was the Speaker terminating debate on a motion the Opposition tabled after only one person from each side had spoken.
Does any of this justify the Opposition’s unruly conduct? Absolutely not. Opposition MPs have a right to be upset and are entitled to express their displeasure, but the way in which they do so must not bring the House into disrepute. The Speaker should be respected. But respect is earned and, if she does not demonstrate the impartiality demanded of her, there will not be peace in the House.
Michael Abrahams is an obstetrician and gynaecologist, social commentator, and human-rights advocate. Send feedback to columns@gleanerjm.com and michabe_1999@hotmail.com, or follow him on X @mikeyabrahams.