Editorial | Vision of Jamaican State
Loading article...
Two seemingly separate, but intertwined, observations by Prime Minister Andrew Holness last week again point to a deeper conversation on the island’s strategies for development and what ought to be the structure of, and expectations from, the Jamaican State.
That debate has special relevance as the island, despite more than a decade and a half of macroeconomic stability, continues its struggle for sustained economic growth and grapples with its efforts at reconstruction from Hurricane Melissa, the Category 5 storm that devastated Jamaica a year ago. It should, therefore, be urgently placed on the national agenda for a holistic conversation rather than, as is largely the case, being addressed in silos.
In remarks at a function at which the National Housing Trust (NHT) – which falls within the prime minister’s portfolio – provided scholarships to 25 students to study engineering and building-related disciplines, Dr Holness repeated his longstanding argument that Jamaica may have to recruit foreign skills, especially in construction, to meet local demand. He raised the issue in the context of the reconstruction of western Jamaica, to be spearheaded by a special-purpose vehicle, the National Reconstruction and Resilience Authority (NaRRA).
“My understanding is that the construction industry has expanded far beyond the labour pool of skills that we have,” the prime minister said. “And it is not just the private firms that complain. The NHT complains as well.”
At the same function, Dr Holness also alluded to the Government’s inability to spend its capital budget annually – a fact he also noted in his other remarks – and said that the country needed experts who can execute projects.
Said the prime minister: “Jamaica has the best planners. They can tell you everything technical, and oftentimes, it comes down to why it can’t be done. We have the brightest people with the brightest ideas. They will give you volumes of paper, but tell them to get it done … That’s what we lack in our society.”
Elsewhere, at the opening of the accident and emergency wing of the Cornwall Regional Hospital (CRH) – the bill for the hospital’s decade-long refurbishment is now J$23.5 billion, nearly 12 times higher than the estimate at the start – Dr Holness said the country didn’t have the expertise to build hospitals, at least not in the same way that it might manage hotels. At the same time, he said that it might have been cheaper to knock down the 10-storey CRH and build a new hospital rather than have attempted to refurbish the old one.
“It is one thing to say, ‘We have the money to spend’,” the prime minister said. “But still, the Ministry of Health, at the end of each year, sends back a large part of its capital budget.”
It is, in part, to circumvent the perceived weaknesses of the Government’s management system and constraining bureaucracy that the Government established NaRRA, with great powers to cut through normal accountability regimes. NaRRA’s powerful CEO reports to the prime minister, and the agency will undertake projects directed by the Cabinet. The agency has no direct and legislatively anchored governance board but an oversight committee appointed by the prime minister to undertake ex post facto reviews of NaRRA operations.
This newspaper said that a centralised fast-track agency and accountable vehicle was necessary to address the post-hurricane destruction of the magnitude left by Hurricane Melissa but with greater oversight than exists with NaRRA.
More important, however, the issues highlighted by Dr Holness are unlikely to find long-term fixes in agencies like NaRRA. The inability to efficiently spend the capital resources allocated by Parliament and the tendency of bureaucrats to engage in what Prime Minister Holness sees as a paralysis by analysis is fundamentally the outcome of the hollowing out of the Jamaican State that has occurred over more than three decades.
As The Gleaner pointed out in the immediate aftermath of last year’s hurricane, the dismantling of many of the institutions of the State during the era of structural adjustment, expecting that their functions would be automatically assumed by the private sector, hasn’t quite worked that way. Markets don’t readily deliver public goods or plan, as the State does, for the future.
In this scenario, relatively low-level and undertrained public-sector employees were expected to oversee multibillion-dollar procurement. Often, what the political executive deemed to be bureaucratic intransigence and overreliance on archaic accountability rules were mere failures to do things right in the first place. The real answer to these problems is not a dismantling of accountability regimes but building the capacity of the State to do its job efficiently.
This was part of the intent in 2022. Under the former finance minister, Nigel Clarke, the Government reclassified jobs and gave some public-sector workers, especially those at the top, substantial salary increases. It is not clear that another critical element of the enterprise was addressed: an upgrading of skill levels in the public sector, especially among policy analysts and procurement officers.
These things are necessary if Jamaica is to construct a genuinely entrepreneurial state. That, though, is not a self-contained project. It must include robust conversations on the kind and level of education and training required for the building of a modern, productive economy and how much Jamaica must invest in research and innovation.
The structured dialogue is long overdue.