Letters November 21 2026

Low-budget behaviour in Parliament

1 min read

Loading article...

THE EDITOR, Sir:

The Parliament is increasingly becoming a spectacle of verbal confrontations, personal insults, and unnecessary theatrics. This is both unfortunate and concerning, as it reflects a growing disregard for the dignity of Parliament.

The recent exchange between the Member of Parliament for West Rural St Andrew, Juliet Cuthbert-Flynn, and the Member of Parliament for Southern St James, Nekeisha Burchell, is another example of how quickly parliamentary disagreements can descend into personal attacks. What began as an exchange over parliamentary preparation deteriorated into remarks about education and professional achievement. Frankly, one has to wonder what value such exchanges bring to the business of Parliament or to the Jamaican people.

Our elected representatives are entrusted with debating legislation, scrutinising government policy, and addressing the concerns of their constituents. Yet, parliamentary proceedings are overshadowed by conduct that would be unacceptable in most professional settings. The public should not have to endure repeated displays of hostility from individuals who are expected to exercise sound judgement, discipline, and leadership.

Withdrawing an offensive remark after it has been made does not necessarily resolve the matter. Where statements are intended to belittle or undermine another person’s character, a genuine apology and an acknowledgement of the harm caused should be part of the process. Parliamentary privilege should not become an excuse for disrespect, nor should political differences be used to justify personal attacks.

The concern is about the example being set and the public’s growing perception of Parliament as a place where disorder and disrespect are becoming normalised. Jamaica faces pressing challenges in education, crime, the economy, healthcare, and national development. These issues require serious discussion, thoughtful deliberation, and responsible leadership, not distractions caused by petty quarrels.

There must be a renewed commitment to civility and accountability in the House. Our parliamentarians do not have to agree, but they should understand that disagreement does not require disrespect. The ability to challenge an argument without attacking the individual is a fundamental part of democratic maturity.

When those elected to lead cannot consistently demonstrate discipline, dignity, and decorum, the public is justified in questioning whether they are adequately fulfilling their responsibilities. Ultimately, Parliament must be judged not by the noise generated within its chambers, but by the quality of its deliberations and the work it accomplishes on behalf of the people.

Jamaica deserves better than low-budget political theatrics.

RICARDO SMITH