Commentary November 22 2026

Omar Sweeney | Decision science and climate change in post-Hurricane Melissa environment

Updated 8 hours ago 3 min read

Loading article...

Omar Sweeney Omar Sweeney. Photo - contributed

When Hurricane Melissa hit Jamaica last year October, a survey of 60 people revealed a 35-per-cent jump in residents’ worries about food, power and property. A handful of residents, a mere fraction of the island’s vulnerable population, was polled before and after the storm.

Their answers, weighted by entropy, showed that fear of food insecurity, electrical power outages and property damage rose sharply, while worries about road conditions and flooding eased. Amid increasingly frequent storms within the Caribbean basin, a new paradigm for decision-making systems for support and response must emerge. An approach that combines residents’ voices captured through carefully constructed surveys, buttressed by engineering data and computer-generated hazard simulations. Decision systems should produce a clear, prioritised list of actions that protects communities and allocates resources more effectively.

WELFARE

A lesson learned after Hurricane Melissa is that the welfare of vulnerable populations is a concern for all Jamaicans. To quote the late, great Bob Marley, “When the rain falls, it don’t fall on one man’s house top.” Our solutions must benefit everyone. The population-at-risk factor combines spatial hazard data with demographic and climate-risk exposure datasets. Analysis of the small dataset revealed a sharp rise in residents’ perceived vulnerability after Hurricane Melissa, which intuitively shows that community-perceived vulnerability can shift drastically overnight after a disaster. This ground-level snapshot underscores the value of a decision system that combines lived experience and expert knowledge to prioritise the protection of vulnerable communities.

The second concept, Multi-Criteria Analysis (MCA), synthesises literature-derived weights and stakeholder-derived weights into a composite to rank infrastructure assets along the five-R criteria (Robustness, Resourcefulness, Resilience, Redundancy, Rapidity) and life-cycle costs, helping planners balance data and practitioner judgment. This approach prioritises evidence-based risk reduction alongside local realities: communities may deprioritise resilient assets they see as less important, while upgrading socially critical but weaker infrastructure. The result is cost-effective investment, stakeholder buy-in and more resilient communities.

A third core element is hazard simulation. Hazard simulation and exposure tools, such as FEMA’s Risk Analysis Planning Tool (FEMA-RAPT), are strong global examples. By inputting scenario-based storm-exposure data, planners obtain a clear picture of potential damage to each asset. Integrating perception, resilience and hazard data enables quantitative, contextual prioritisation.

The decision system can be built on three essential pillars: (1) stakeholder surveys that capture lived experience, quantified into a “resilience score” integrating the particularities of each community instead of imposing a one-size-fits-all model; (2) Multi-Criteria Analysis (MCA) that blends hard data, such as road redundancy, bridge robustness and life-cycle costs, with soft factors like the quality of governance and institutional support. The decision model stays grounded while still honouring expert judgment; and (3) hazard simulation and exposure tools like the Jamaica Systemic Risk Assessment Tool (J-SRAT), hosted by the PIOJ, and the National Risk Information Platform, hosted by the ODPEM. These platforms predict storm exposure and impact for each infrastructure asset and can output vulnerability scores that can be visualised across the island.

ALIGN

The next step is to align multiple agencies, based on capacity and strength, to own and execute aspects of the designed cycle. This cycle, survey –> weighting –> simulation –> refinement, ensures that decision-making remains adaptive and responsive to both data and community voice. The usefulness lies in its simplicity and transparency. The survey requires only basic data collection, spreadsheet calculations, and limited staff or funding. Experts and community members can see how subjective judgements shape final priorities, promoting buy-in and accountability. By feeding the composite scores into hazard simulation engines like the J-SRAT, planners can quantify potential storm damage and tailor resource allocation to the most vulnerable points in the local infrastructure network.

The power of this decision system lies in its capacity to integrate feedback. Community members, stakeholders, local municipalities and infrastructure agencies like the National Works Agency identify gaps or mismatches, and the tool is refined. All artifacts from the survey are fully documented; other islands can transplant the framework. This decision-support system is built on everyday voices and rigorous science, empowering vulnerable communities and countries to outmanoeuvre climate’s most devastating impacts. Right here in Jamaica, we can turn our own data into a strategic roadmap that points exactly to where emergency funds, engineering upgrades and protective regulations should go.

Omar Sweeney is the managing director of JSIF. He is a civil engineer currently conducting doctoral research at the University of Florida’s Engineering School of Sustainable Infrastructure and Environment (ESSIE). Send feedback to osweeney@ufl.edu.